Don Caballero was formed in Pittsburgh in 1991 by drummer Damon Che (b. Damon Fitzgerald), guitarists Ian Williams and Mike Banfield, and bassist Pat Morris. Individual veterans of the local scene, they had offers for gigs before they'd even found a lead singer, and simply wound up remaining instrumental. Their name was taken from an SCTV sketch in which the Joe Flaherty character Guy Caballero was made a Mafia don. Through some personal contacts, the band got a chance to enter the studio with producer Steve Albini, who recommended them to Touch & Go Records. Don Caballero released several singles on Touch & Go before completing their Steve Albini-produced debut, For Respect, in 1993.
Pat Morris departed following its release, and was replaced by Matt Jencik for Don Caballero 2, a loud, ugly, intricate album that was released to rapturous reviews in 1995. Hailed as a math rock landmark in some quarters, 2 expanded the group's audience by leaps and bounds. In its wake, several Caballero side projects sprang up: Che played guitar in another Pittsburgh band called the(e) Speaking Canaries, who issued an album not long after; Williams, meanwhile, formed an experimental side project called Storm & Stress, which was most often based in Chicago. Meanwhile, Matt Jencik left the band, and went on to play with Hurl and Taking Pictures; his spot was eventually filled by Storm & Stress bassist Eric Emm (aka Erich Ehm, b. M. Eric Topolsky). This new lineup released What Burns Never Returns in 1998, after which Mike Banfield left the group, reducing them to a trio.
A compilation of Don Caballero's early formative singles appeared in 1999, under the title Singles Breaking Up, Vol. 1 (a reference to the Buzzcocks' Singles Going Steady). In 2000, the group issued its fourth proper album, the cleaner-sounding and more subdued American Don, which again won complimentary reviews. However, intra-band tensions conspired to break up the group by 2001. Williams and Emm returned to Storm & Stress, and Williams also formed a new outfit called Battles with Helmet drummer John Stanier. Che, meanwhile, formed Bellini in 2002 with two members of Sicilian prog rockers Uzeda. However, he left after their first album to re-form Don Caballero with an entirely new lineup, merging himself into a Pittsburgh-based Don Cab-influenced math rock outfit formerly known as Creta Bourzia. The group returned in 2006 with World Class Listening Problem on the Relapse label. After recording in Rust Belt Studios with producer Al Sutton, Punkgasm was released in August of 2008, followed by a tour with Ponytail in support of the album. In 2012 archival live recording Gang Banged with a Headache and Live surfaced, a fuzzy document of a show in Chicago recorded in 2003. ~ Steve Huey