Henderson recruited guitarist Patrick Fetkowitz, keyboard player Matt Warner, bassist Dan Travis, and drummer Rob Griffith, and the band began to play around New England and in New York, attracting fans and management. They released their self-titled debut EP on March 18, 2008, followed in 2009 by their first full-length, Old Time Speaker. For their next studio outing, the band headed to Norman, Oklahoma with OTS producer Chad Copelin. The resulting Shake! Shake! Shake! helped further establish the band's profile, eliciting a bevy of licensing opportunities in both film and television. The group returned to the East Coast, again with Copelin, for their third long-player, 2013's Up, On & Over. ~ William Ruhlmann