AJ Lee

This one’s a bit of a stretch, but we’re using WWE logic, which means nothing has to make sense and anything can happen. The last time we saw AJ was at WrestleMania 31, promptly followed by her retirement from the sport. Since that time, Mrs. CM Punk has been under the radar, enjoying life outside of WWE. The big question is why would she want to return? And more specifically, as Sister Abigail? Since her husband’s not on good terms with the company, it’s likely that she’ll stand by his side and not cross the line to come back.

However, getting to be part of a major WrestleMania angle with a partner as interesting as Bray Wyatt, that might be enough to have her mull over the possibility. Maybe Sister Abigail possesses AJ’s body or is one of the personalities AJ has rotating in her head. There’s many creative ways to work her into the role.