On tonight’s premiere of Property Brothers at Home: Drew’s Honeymoon House, Drew’s identical twin and costar, Jonathan, and their older brother, J.D., join the HGTV realtor as he tries on tuxedos for his wedding to fiancée Linda Phan in May.

Upon arrival to The Black Tux in Santa Monica, California, Jonathan and J.D. don two very different, but equally over-the-top, first looks. Jonathan’s references the family’s Scottish heritage with a two-toned plaid number, while J.D. opts to omit a shirt under his blush pink blazer.

Both eventually take their selections a bit more seriously, with Jonathan changing into a kilt made from “the actual Scott tartan,” and J.D. finding a white button up.

“All jokes aside, for the first time, this is actually hitting me,” Drew says in the clip. “This is actually happening. I’m getting married!”

With their upcoming destination affair in Italy just a few months away, Drew and Linda have been getting wedding planning in where they can, a tricky feat as they film for the HGTV series and Drew competes on Dancing with the Stars. But in this week’s issue of PEOPLE, the two reveal that they’ve found time to taste cakes at Magnolia Bakery and nail down the big day’s menu.

“We’re looking at somewhere where we can chow down on pizza, pasta and gelato. Those are the requirements,” says Phan, who has also done a little dress shopping of her own at Claire Pettibone Dress Shop in L.A.

The late-night spread sounds just as tasty, and is slated to include burgers, fries and (as a tribute to Drew’s Scottish roots) Yorkshire pudding.

“This is our big day—we can do whatever we want!” Drew says. “One of the things that I love about Linda is that she’s with me in that sense. If I want to wear a gold leotard, I’ll do it. We’re not ones to have a basic white wedding.”